Thursday, January 17, 2008

American Idol is back! (or how I plan to lose several IQ points in the coming weeks)


Confession time:

This week, upon the return of "American Idol" to the TV lineup, I spent a solid four hours watching heavily deluded, tone-deaf people have their grossly misguided dreams crushed by the ever-amused trio of judges: Randy, Paula and Simon.

And it was hysterical.

After six seasons of the show, you would think viewers would be sick of watching vocally challenged Americans line up by the tens of thousands for a chance to show us all just how terrible they are at singing. But you'd be wrong, cause we're not.

I suppose "American Idol" is best known to many as a singing competition between a couple dozen finalists, on whom the viewers vote via phone calls and text messages each week, until a winner is selected and vaulted to semi-stardom in the pop music world -- or else a single Ford commercial and then total oblivion, depending on their mass market appeal.

But there are those of us who prefer the season's earlier episodes -- the auditions. These follow a careful formula:

1. We watch two to three scenes of atrocious singers butchering a song that wasn't very good to start with, after which the judges (depending on their moods) either insult them or say 'you're nice, but keep your day job' and send them on their way.

2. Then we get to see one pretty good singer (or one pretty girl, whose singing doesn't sound like the screech of a cat being raped), and that person gets a "golden ticket" to compete in the next round in Hollywood.

3. We see a vignette telling us about some contestant's life, including video clips of them working on the farm or drawing artwork or whatever they do in their real life, and we get to meet their families. The sadder his/her story, the more likely that he/she will be a terrible singer and then the judges will have to try not to laugh or verbally abuse them while telling them they should never, ever sing a song again.

4. We see a contestant who either A) is mentally disabled or B) knowingly came to the audition to do something deliberately dumb or (if we're lucky) funny on national television. Here, Randy and Paula laugh and say 'thanks for coming, now please leave' and Simon scowls and motions for security to escort this person out of the room.

5. We're taken into commercial break by a montage of people badly and comically singing the same song (while the original recording of the song plays in the background, so that we will actually know what song it is that these people are supposed to be singing). Ryan Seacrest is also there.

And that, folks, is fantastic television.

I am fully aware that parts of it are rather mean and demeaning, as I probably laughed at some mentally retarded people last night and Tuesday. Also, the whole thing is very repetitive and borderline obnoxious.

But none of that, nor the realization that I am probably losing an IQ point for every hour I watch, can tear me away. I am addicted.

This truly is people-watching at its finest. It's the highlight reel of people watching. You know, some people will sit at a mall or an airport for hours waiting to catch a glimpse of one weirdo, dressed bizarrely and saying freaking stuff. Well, I can get two solid hours of that from the comfort of my couch.

Even better, I've noticed that something about singing brings out the inner absurdities of people who might come off as reasonably sane in a conversation or other average situation.

So, moral of the story is: don't wait around to watch the finals of "American Idol," when they'll try to convince you that one of these mediocre singers is the next Top 40 superstar.

Watch now, when the whole point is laughing at these fools.

8 comments:

Courtney said...

I watched it too. I'm not proud, but it is damn entertaining.

What I don't understand is why the camera crew follows someone around, sometimes even going to their home or work, and then it turns out that that person is a terrible singer. Why waste our time with the dude who mows lawns for a living and sings like a dying cat?

Mickey and I were cracking up at the guy at the end of last night's show, the one in your picture. My lord, that was hilarious.

Meaghan said...

Watching the show is a little like riding a roller coaster... oh wait, some guy just said that last night and I think he had some kind of disorder.

Anyway, you may think one person sounds good one moment, then not two seconds later, the worst sound you ever heard is coming from the same TV.

Plus, there are the crazy stalkers, the people willing to wax their chest hair for Paula, other people trying to associate with Randy by calling him "dog" and of course the costumes. But my all-time favorite is the bitch(es) who has to flip off the camera after they leave the room. Last year it was Ronetta(sp?), who apparently wasn't wearing any panties. This year it was Janice Joplin wannabe and Princess Laya.

Julie said...

I haven't had time to watch a lot of tv lately (not that there would be anything worth watching if I did), but I have watched this in the past and would do so again although it makes me physically uncomfortable. I can only hope these people are oblivious.

Wait... are you just trying to gain more google hits?

Mickey said...

How awesome was that guy in the photo, and I don't mean awesomely bad? That dude was absolutely genuine, wanted nothing but to spread a little happiness (notably to Simon), and even wrote an original song that's still stuck in my head. Courtney was right when she told me that they really built that guy up throughout the show and he didn't disappoint.

Chris said...

Sadly, no, Julie. This post was not a mere ploy for Google hits. This was genuinely the topic on my mind for the day.

Courtney and Mickey: that last guy really did make the show. I'm sure he'll show up on YouTube eventually, for those of you who didn't see him. And I suspect Simon might have been right in predicting his little song will be a hit record in the near future.

Nicole said...

I have a confession. We have our Tivo set to record the entire season. Eee!

Senegal Daily said...

You know, I have actually only ever seen about 15 minutes of AI. I moved right as it was coming out.

But...there is a French version called 'Star Academy'. (If you don't speak French, that's pronounced: STAH-rah-KAH-tehm-ee.)

I have no doubt I'd be addicted in the US. At least for the earlier episodes in season.

Jacob said...

I am now saddened for the future of our culture for the first time in my life.